Pittsburgh IT Company Shares Tips for Selecting a Trusted MSP
In fact, managed IT services can reduce your recurring in-house costs by up to 40%, while boosting efficiency by 50 to 60%. With numbers like that, it’s no surprise that more businesses are making the shift to outsourced IT.
In this guide from a reliable IT company in Pittsburgh, we’ll walk you through the top managed services selection criteria, critical MSP qualifying questions, and how to find a provider that delivers real, long-term value.
As George Hammerschmidt, Executive VP and COO at Nortec, says, “A great MSP isn’t just about fixing problems. They prevent them, align with your goals, and operate like a true extension of your team.”
How to Choose a Managed Services Provider That Actually Meets Your Needs
Before reaching out to any vendors, take time to define what your business really needs from a managed IT provider. This helps you avoid getting distracted by flashy features or generic promises and focus on real solutions that fit your goals.
Think about:
- Do you need basic help desk support, or full IT management?
- Are cybersecurity and compliance big priorities?
- Do you need support for remote work, cloud systems, or legacy tools?
This is the foundation of your managed services selection criteria. When you’re clear on your needs, it’s much easier to evaluate providers and ask smart questions, like those in a managed IT services questionnaire or MSP discovery call.
Start by creating a short checklist that reflects your business:
- What are your pain points?
- What are your current IT gaps?
- What level of support do you expect?
- What outcomes matter most (cost savings, faster support, better security)?
Answering these will guide everything else — and help you choose the right MSP, not just the most popular one.
Key Managed Services Selection Criteria
Not all providers offer the same level of service. Here are the top things to look for:
1.Proven Experience in Your Industry
Different industries have different needs. Whether you’re in healthcare, finance, education, or retail, your MSP should understand your unique compliance, security, and workflow challenges. Ask for examples or case studies that show their track record.
2.Security and Compliance Focus
Security is no longer optional. A qualified MSP should have security built into every part of their service. Look for:
- 24/7 threat detection and response
- Patch and update management
- Multi-factor authentication (MFA)
- Backup and disaster recovery
- Documentation to support audits and compliance
If you’re in a regulated industry like healthcare or finance, this is critical.
3.Scalability and Flexibility
Your technology needs will change. Make sure your MSP can support:
- Future office locations
- Hybrid or remote teams
- New software rollouts
- Sudden growth or changes
Scalability means you won’t outgrow your provider.
4.Transparent and Predictable Pricing
Hidden fees can wreck your IT budget. The right MSP will offer:
- Clear, detailed proposals
- Flat-rate monthly pricing
- Tiered options that fit your business size and needs
Pricing transparency also builds trust from day one.
5.Proactive Monitoring and Support
Waiting until something breaks is expensive. A strong MSP will:
- Monitor your systems around the clock
- Catch issues before they impact your business
- Offer real-time support when problems arise
This level of service keeps your business running smoothly.
6. Secure and Limit API Access
APIs need to be as secure as any other system entry point.
- Use authentication tokens and rate limiting
- Keep an API gateway in place to manage traffic
- Log and monitor all API activity
7. Use Cloud Access Security Brokers (CASBs)
CASBs act as a control point between your users and cloud service providers.
- Gain visibility into shadow IT and unsanctioned cloud apps
- Enforce security policies across cloud services
- Monitor user behavior to detect anomalies
Cloud Risk vs. Mitigation Strategy
| Risk | Mitigation Strategy |
| Unauthorized data access | MFA, encryption, role-based access control |
| Insider error or abuse | Activity monitoring, user training, least-privilege model |
| Exploitable misconfigurations | Regular audits, automated compliance checks |
| Shadow IT | CASBs, visibility tools, usage policies |
| DDoS or service disruption | Auto-scaling, traffic filtering, incident response plans |
Questions to Ask During MSP Discovery
Asking the right questions helps you qualify the provider, not just based on sales talk, but based on capability.
Here are essential MSP qualifying questions:
- What industries do you specialize in?
- Can you walk us through your onboarding process?
- How do you handle after-hours emergencies?
- What’s your typical response time?
- What security standards and frameworks do you follow?
- Can you provide client references?
- Do you offer quarterly reviews or strategy sessions?
These questions go beyond surface-level and help you assess whether the MSP will be a true partner.
Red Flags to Watch Out For When Choosing an MSP
| Red Flag | Why It’s a Red Flag | What to Do |
| Vague SLAs | No clear expectations means misaligned support. | Ask for a detailed SLA with measurable commitments. |
| Promises That Sound Too Good to Be True | Could indicate overpromising without the capability to deliver. | Look for realistic offerings and verify claims. |
| No Industry Experience or Case Studies | Lack of experience could lead to misunderstandings or poor service. | Request industry-specific references or case studies. |
| No Proactive Monitoring or Maintenance | Indicates they may only respond to problems, not prevent them. | Ensure they offer proactive monitoring services. |
| One-Size-Fits-All Packages | Your business is unique, and needs tailored solutions. | Ask about customizable packages that fit your needs. |
How to Choose a Managed IT Provider with a Trusted IT Firm in Pittsburgh
Choosing a managed IT provider is more than a tech decision. It’s about finding a long-term partner who supports your growth, strengthens your security, and helps your team succeed.
A great MSP will:
- Understand your industry and goals
- Prevent problems before they start
- Help you scale securely
- Communicate clearly and consistently
At Nortec, we’ve helped businesses across industries modernize and protect their IT without the stress. From daily support to strategic planning, our team becomes a trusted extension of yours.
Contact a trusted Pittsburgh IT company today and learn how it can support your business.
